An excerpt from my script review for What Could Have Been: The Umbra by Steven Karczynski which will be available 11/17/26:
2.) Plot Stability
Delaying the Payoff
Before I give you my back and forth with AI, I wanted to establish a few things.
Was this script well written? Yes.
Was the tension interesting and appropriate with David as he became more paranoid about the tape and the people trying to find it? Again, yes.
Now, you can probably figure out my biggest issue from the previous section with the script…
(Here we go, back to my discussion with ChatGPT on this one!)
ChatGPT: Okay, I’ve got The Umbra—97 pages, Steven Karczynski’s original screenplay.
And having read the opening and the ending, I can already see why you described the payoff as underwhelming.
The premise is genuinely unsettling. An ordinary suburban guy finds a cassette in his mailbox, discovers something that terrifies him, and gradually realizes he’s stumbled into a conspiracy much bigger than himself.
But the ending confirms something interesting about your criticism: Karczynski isn’t simply withholding information from David. He’s deliberately withholding it from the reader, even after David knows what’s on the tape.
That’s a tricky storytelling choice. It can create tremendous suspense, but it also creates an obligation to deliver a revelation worthy of all that secrecy.
The final revelation—that people are being processed and disposed of beneath an unsuspecting population—is disturbing. But it doesn’t feel quite as devastating as the screenplay has repeatedly promised.
What I do like is Karczynski’s handling of David’s growing paranoia. The suspicious strangers, the apparent surveillance, and even the smallest disturbances in his orderly life create some effective tension. The home invasion is particularly nasty.
So my initial impression is that Karczynski has a stronger command of suspense than revelation. The screenplay has some genuinely cinematic sequences, but it relies heavily on the audience not knowing something that the protagonist already knows.
I wouldn’t necessarily conclude that Karczynski didn’t know his ending when he started writing. But I can certainly understand why it feels that way.
One thing I’d love to discuss before we put together your review: Did you find David interesting enough as a character to carry the story independently of the conspiracy? I think that question could be just as important as the disappointing payoff.
ME: david was fine, and yes the suspense with him was good. readers/audiences will just have a hard time NOT knowing what’s on the tape aside from the drips we get, the beginning of which is always repeated from what we last heard.
like you said “That’s a tricky storytelling choice.” that’s the overall premise of my review, and if you don’t deliver on something worthwhile, they’ll be mad at you for it.
case and point the END of the tape, which we finally get DOES NOT allude to the “human processing” that David experiences at the end, therefore i have a hard time believing he’d be “curled up on the bathroom floor” after listening to it.
ChatGPT: I think you’ve identified the screenplay’s biggest weakness, and having gone back through those scenes, I agree with your reasoning.
Karczynski asks us to accept David’s emotional reaction without giving us sufficient evidence to justify it.
On page 25, David listens to the tape and experiences escalating horror. By page 26, he’s physically sick, and the following morning he’s waking up screaming on the bathroom floor.
That’s an enormous reaction. Naturally, we assume he’s heard something almost unimaginable.
But when we finally hear the conclusion of the recording on pages 94–96, Lazar describes thousands of people lined up for disposal. It’s horrifying information, certainly, but the tape never clearly explains the grotesque processing procedure David experiences firsthand.
The distinction is important: David’s fate is considerably more disturbing than the revelation that supposedly traumatized him in the first place.
And your other observation is equally valid. Karczynski repeatedly returns to the tape, replaying familiar dialogue before revealing another small piece of information. Instead of progressively satisfying our curiosity, he keeps postponing the answer.
I think there’s a strong central argument for your review:
The screenplay confuses withholding information with building suspense. Those techniques can work together, but they’re not interchangeable. The longer a writer keeps the audience waiting for an answer, the greater the expectation that the eventual revelation will justify the wait.
What’s particularly frustrating is that Karczynski demonstrates he knows how to build suspense through David’s experiences. He doesn’t need to rely so heavily on the cassette gimmick.
I wouldn’t call The Umbra a bad screenplay. I’d call it an effective paranoid thriller undermined by an unsatisfying central mystery.
And I think that’s a fair assessment that gives Karczynski credit for what he does well without letting him off the hook for the ending.
One question: Did you also find the alien conspiracy itself somewhat conventional? Because I wonder whether part of the disappointment comes from expecting something genuinely original after such an elaborate buildup.
ME: “The distinction is important: David’s fate is considerably more disturbing than the revelation that supposedly traumatized him in the first place.” This!
ChatGPT: And THAT should be the centerpiece of your review.
David’s fate is considerably more disturbing than the revelation that supposedly traumatized him in the first place.
That’s the fundamental disconnect in The Umbra. Karczynski spends much of the screenplay promising something so horrific that it leaves David physically and psychologically shattered. But when the audience finally learns what he heard, the revelation doesn’t justify the reaction.
Worse, the truly horrifying material comes afterward, when David experiences it firsthand.
The writer essentially delivers the payoff to a different setup than the one we’ve spent the entire screenplay anticipating.
That’s a strong criticism without being unfair to an otherwise entertaining thriller.
Alright…AI time over.
And it is the centerpiece of what we can learn from this script.
Don’t disappoint your audience with an underwhelming payoff.
David has this guttural reaction that suggests whatever was on that tape was so horrible it made him physically ill, curled up in the fetal position on the bathroom floor.
But what did we hear?
Honestly, like ChatGPT’s question about the “alien conspiracy” I’m unsure, because the end of Lazar’s tape of the meeting, just like the ending, is so vague we’re unsure what people being “processed” actually means.
Lazar has a negative reaction to it, but doesn’t go into any real length on it that we can “see” it via his description, and frankly he shouldn’t have to do that.
Sure David gets a tube shoved down his throat and black liquid forced into his lungs/body, but that’s not on the tape!
(So David wouldn’t have heard it and would have been just as in the dark as we were.)
Nor would I argue it’s a worthy payoff for the “stalling” presented by the writer.
Like the AI criticism, “The screenplay confuses withholding information with building suspense.”
And that’s a shame because Karczynski does a really good job of making David (and in turn us) paranoid by whatever government agency is trying to recover the tape from him.
One final thought here…I don’t understand why he didn’t try and contact a Saul Goodman style attorney when he guessed or knew the police were compromised.
He was smart enough to hide a copy in a safety deposit box.
Want EARLY access to our videos, uploads, and movie/script reviews? Members get them FIRST! Follow this link to our Discussion Forum.




